The Legal Examiner Affiliate Network The Legal Examiner The Legal Examiner The Legal Examiner search instagram avvo phone envelope checkmark mail-reply spinner error close The Legal Examiner The Legal Examiner The Legal Examiner
Skip to main content

Sometimes judges get tangled up in abstractions when the simple facts and proper path is clear. If I handed a gun to a 6 year old and said “Go out and play,” isn’t that a clear violation of a state law as well as very negligent? Or, is that just a parental decision? A Florida appellate court has ruled it is just a business owner’s managerial decision to order an employee to drive a motorcycle without a proper license. The employee was killed on the motorcycle – a result that would probably be more predictable than the self-inflicted gunshot wound death of the 6 year old.

Excerpts from the St. Pete Times story:

Shirley Ivey sued David M. Woodson, owner of Keepit-Safe Security Storage Systems in Crystal River, claiming Woodson’s negligence caused her son, Christopher G. Tenner, to die in a 2002 motorcycle accident. A jury agreed, and in a final judgment issued last August Circuit Judge Patricia Thomas ordered Woodson to pay Tenner’s family $343,622.40 to cover funeral expenses, loss of support and mental anguish.

But the appeals court ruled Friday that Woodson’s decision to allow Ivey’s son to drive his motorcycle was a managerial one, entitling him to immunity under Florida’s Worker’s Compensation Act.

Comments for this article are closed.